The November 3 election has renewed attention on a proposal that could change how the United States chooses its president, and Michigan may play an important role in what happens next.
In a November 14 report for Votebeat, Nathaniel Rakich examines the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement among states that would award their Electoral College votes to the presidential candidate who receives the most votes nationwide.
Following the 2026 midterm elections, the compact has a potential path to taking effect before the 2028 presidential election. Whether that happens will depend on decisions by several state legislatures, including Michigan’s, and unresolved legal questions.
How Does the National Popular Vote Compact Work?
Under the current system, Americans vote for president within their states, and the Electoral College determines the winner. Most states award all their electoral votes to the candidate who wins that state’s popular vote.
That means a candidate can win the presidency without receiving the most votes nationwide, as happened in 2000 and 2016.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would change how participating states award their electoral votes.
States that join agree to award all their electoral votes to the presidential candidate who wins the national popular vote, even if another candidate receives more votes within their own state.
The agreement takes effect only when participating states collectively control at least 270 of the Electoral College’s 538 votes, enough to determine the presidential winner.
The Electoral College would continue to exist, but the votes of participating states would be awarded according to the nationwide result.
Currently, 18 states and Washington, D.C., have enacted the compact, representing 222 electoral votes. Another 48 electoral votes are needed for it to take effect.
Why Is Michigan Part of the Conversation?
Michigan has 15 electoral votes and has considered joining the compact before.
In July 2026, lawmakers introduced House Bill 6213, which would enter Michigan into the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. The bill has not become law.
Following the November 3 election, Democrats are positioned to control Michigan’s governorship and both chambers of the Legislature beginning in 2027.
That change has brought renewed attention to the proposal.
As Ballotpedia reported on November 11, incoming Michigan Senate Majority Leader Darrin Camilleri has acknowledged that Michigan could be one of the states whose decision determines whether the compact reaches the required 270 electoral votes.
Arizona, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin are also being watched because of changes in political control following the midterm elections.
Those five states alone account for 61 electoral votes. If enough of them join, the compact could reach the threshold before the next presidential election.
However, legislative control does not guarantee passage. Lawmakers and governors in each state would still have to decide whether to adopt the agreement.
What Would Change for Voters?
Supporters of the compact argue that a national popular vote would give presidential campaigns a reason to compete for votes throughout the country, including in states where the outcome is usually predictable.
Under the current Electoral College system, presidential campaigns concentrate significant attention and resources on a relatively small number of competitive states.
With a national popular vote, votes cast in every state would contribute to the same nationwide total that determines the winning candidate.
Critics raise concerns about states awarding their electoral votes to a candidate who did not win their own state’s popular vote. Some also argue that a national system could shift campaign attention toward more densely populated areas.
The compact would not establish uniform voting laws across the country. States would continue to have different rules for voter registration, absentee voting, and voting eligibility.
Those differences raise additional questions about how a national popular vote would operate across states with different election procedures.
What Legal Questions Remain?
Even if enough states join the compact, its implementation could face significant legal challenges.
As Votebeat explains, one issue concerns the U.S. Constitution’s Compact Clause, which limits certain agreements between states without congressional approval.
Legal scholars disagree about whether the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would require that approval.
Other questions concern states’ constitutional authority to determine how presidential electors are selected and whether differences in state voting laws could create constitutional challenges under the Equal Protection Clause.
The outcome of those legal questions remains uncertain.
For the compact to apply to the 2028 presidential election, enough states would need to have joined and their participation would need to be in effect by July 20, 2028, the deadline specified in the agreement.
Follow the Issue and Get Involved
VAAC works closely with Common Cause on voting rights and election protection efforts. Common Cause is also advocating for Michigan to join the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
With Michigan lawmakers expected to revisit the proposal in 2027, Common Cause is encouraging residents to contact their state legislators in support of the compact.
Readers interested in supporting this effort can sign Common Cause’s Michigan-specific petition, which calls on Michigan lawmakers to adopt the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
Michigan residents can also follow the legislation and contact their elected representatives directly to share their views.
Why This Matters for Understanding Elections
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact raises questions about how presidential elections translate individual votes into an Electoral College outcome, how states exercise their authority over elections, and whether the current system should change.
Last week, VAAC examined proportional representation and political power, including how different systems translate votes into legislative seats.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact addresses a different issue: how the winner of a presidential election is determined. It does not propose proportional allocation of seats in Congress or state legislatures.
Both discussions provide opportunities to examine the rules that shape elections and political representation.
Michigan’s consideration of the compact will be one development to follow as the new legislative session begins in 2027.
